Okay. This is going to be nowhere near complete, ever, but it'll always be a work in progress, at least. I've easily been to a few hundred live shows, and most of the memorable ones are the ones that were either really good, or REALLY bad. Rated *-*****, with ***** being the best.
In the order I remember them. If you're looking for something specific, just use the "find" thing in your browser:
Lightning Bolt,
PussyGutt, and a couple other bands that weren't as good. *****
Pussygutt wasn't having a great night, and honestly, the outdoor amphitheater on the greenbelt was probably not the best place for their music. Lightning Bolt, on the other hand, fucking killed it. Best show I've ever been to.
Wolves in the Throne Room,
Manville, and a couple others. *****
This show was out in the woods last October. WitTR are probably my favorite metal band right now, and seeing them play around a fucking bonfire in the woods is probably a good bit of the reason for that.
Jeffrey Lewis *****
This show was actually a lot more fun than it should've been. It started in a record shop. Then it kinda moved to a basement. This was when he was touring
12 Crass Songs, and his girlfriend was playing keyboards. Five stars because he played
Williamsburg Will Oldham Horror and
Back When I Was 4.
The Halo Benders *****
A lot of fun. I can't remember who all opened, but it didn't really matter because it was the fucking Halo Benders. Calvin Johnson seemed surprisingly okay with being there. Some dude drove to Boise all the way from Pennsylvania to come to this show. That guy ruled. Comical moments included watching Calvin Johnson attempt to sell t-shirts that say "Impeach" on them to a predominantly red state crowd from the stage, and hearing some dude tell him (Calvin) a story about a time he (Calvin) was rude to one of his friends.
The Rolling Stones ***
I'm glad I didn't pay for this one. My cousin managed to get me tickets. While they're still entertaining enough, arena shows just never fail to leave a bad taste in my mouth. I understand that there's no other way the Stones could really tour, but I'm not really taking that into consideration here. Also,
Blue October was opening, and honestly, they bored the hell out of me.
Converge,
The Red Chord,
Genghis Tron,
Blacklisted *****
Probably one of the best hardcore shows I've ever been to. Small venue. Complete disregard for its rules on the part of the fans. No barrier between the crowd and the stage. People were taking dives off the PA. A hell of a lot of fun.
Converge,
Mastodon,
The Bronx ***
The venue for this one was a bit bigger than the more recent show (above), and honestly, Mastodon bores the hell out of me live (sorry, but they do). The venue's security acted like a bunch of assholes through the whole show, but thankfully, The Bronx were fun, and Converge tore it up. I was ready to leave about a quarter of the way through Mastodon's set, but I decided to force a fair listen instead. I haven't liked them since.
Mastodon,
Against Me!,
Cursive,
Planes Mistaken for Stars *
I could've done without Against Me! and Mastodon on this show because they brought out one of the shittiest crowds I've ever seen. During Against Me!'s set, it was a total bro-fest. They only played new songs, mostly off of
New Wave, which at the time hadn't been released so no one knew the songs. All the Mastodon fans who'd been drawn in by promotion on the local "rock" (read: mostly nu-metal) radio station were heckling the other bands through their sets. During Mastodon's set the PA kept cutting out, and they actually sounded
better that way. The rest of their set sounded like crap because of the earsplitting distortion. Apparently they brought their own PA. Cursive played an alright set, but they weren't really loud enough. Planes Mistaken For Stars started a half hour before they were supposed to because the venue decided to make them. Overall, they were the only band that ended up being worth watching, and it was nice that none of the Mastodon fans had shown up yet when they went on. Still, this show was a complete train wreck.
Cursive,
The Thermals,
Chin Up Chin Up ****
This show was a hell of a lot of fun. Before it I caught Tim Kasher playing an "acoustic" (it was billed as acoustic, but he played an electric guitar without distortion) set accompanied by a trumpet player at a record shop. He did an awesome version of
At Conception. They were in good form at the show itself, too. The Thermals were fucking fun. That's all there is to it. Really, really awesome people, too. Chin Up Chin Up didn't do much for me, but they weren't awful. This was a pretty fun show.
Against Me!,
The Epoxies,
The Soviettes,
Smoke or Fire ****
This show was a hell of a lot of fun. The Epoxies put on a killer set. Definitely the highlight of the night. Against Me! played their old songs and were pretty into it. The crowd was insane. The other bands weren't really my cuppa tea, but neither of them were bad.
Bright Eyes,
Nik Freitas ****
Bright Eyes were good. They played a lot of their "hits" and threw in a couple more unexpected songs like
True Blue and
Padraic My Prince. Conor looked drunk as hell. Nik Freitas was pretty boring, though. Definitely nothing special. What I found particularly interesting was the mix of people this show brought out. There were people there I hadn't seen since the last time I went to a street punk show, and there were frat boys, middle-aged housewives, hipsters, and everyone in between. I wish more shows brought out crowds like that.
Planes Mistaken for Stars ****
This show was just confusing. It was originally two shows. It ended up just being one big overbooked mess. Gordie Howe Trio Unit played in a garage where the show was initially supposed to take place. Then for some reason, it was abruptly moved to the bar where the second show was taking place. Planes fucking killed it. They played a lot of songs off
Mercy, which is definitely something I can get behind. I think The Adversives, Vagerfly, and a few others played this, too.
Sigur Rós,
Amiina *****
Fuck the naysayers. Sigur Ros is awesome live. It was a relatively small venue (it would be big for anything else, but Sigur Ros are good at filling large spaces, so it worked out okay). They were really pleasant dudes after the show, too.
The Decemberists,
Cass McCombs **
The Decemberists tried. They really did. But their fatigue showed through to the point where I just kinda wish they'd cancelled and come back some other time. They really didn't want to be playing that show, and all the stage antics came off half-assed and just kind of bummed me out. Cass McCombs was boring as hell. His whole band spent the entire show seated and looked bored through the whole thing. It was just kind of awkward, and they just played kind of generic coffee shop singer/songwriter stuff. Yuck.
The Old Haunts ****
This one was in a living room that I swore was going to collapse under the weight of all the people dancing in it. The bassist was playing in the hallway to the kitchen by the end of the set because the crowd had actually pushed him out of the room thanks to how awkwardly the band had set up.
The Lawrence Arms,
The Draft ****
The atmosphere for this show was honestly pretty bad. Not nearly enough people showed up. Which is a damn shame, because The Lawrence Arms are one of the best pop-punk bands still around and played an awesome set, mostly from
Oh! Calcutta!. The Draft were pretty good, too. I like them a lot better than most people seem to, and honestly, I think they're a hell of a lot better than most later Hot Water Music. I just wish more people had showed up.
Casiotone for the Painfully Alone,
Foot Foot ****
Foot Foot didn't really do much to me, and I can't really think of much to say about Casiotone live except it was better than you'd think. It's really hard to put it into words. So basically it's some guy using a pile of keyboards as a confessional booth in a really awkward way. "Entertaining" or "fun" are definitely not the right words, but I enjoyed the show.
The Sword,
Slough Feg *****
This is probably the most insane show I've ever been to at the Neurolux. Broken glass on the floor. Some girl mackin' on one of my friends all night. People actually acting like they're at a metal show in a bar. Probably one of the most fun shows I've ever seen at a place usually dominated by boring hipster types.
The Black Angels,
Vietnam,
The Heavenly States *****
I was tired as hell, and sort of drunk at this show. Still, this is some of the best modern psych-rock you're going to catch live. Good for a night out when you just need something to completely sonically destroy your brain.
The Hold Steady,
The Heartless Bastards ****
I have to deduct a star for The Heartless Bastards, who have the "semi-attractive female singer in shitty bar rock band" thing going on in spades. People in the bar loved it, but man, they blew. Really generic and uninteresting, and their singer tries to pull off these embarrassing "bluesy" vocal inflections that just don't work. The Hold Steady were so incredibly goddamn fun, however, that I quickly forgot about them and had a really, really good fucking time.
Total Chaos,
Naked Aggression ***
Total Chaos were pretty straight-up street punk stuff. At the time, I was going through a phase and ate it up, but in retrospect, they really didn't have much going on other than fancy haircuts and image-appropriate pants and jackets. Naked Aggression were better, but they have not aged gracefully. Apparently their singer went on to be a school teacher, and comes off much like you'd expect, considering. Three stars for nostalgia, but unless you're really into that sort of thing, you might not find either of these bands all that interesting.
Ceremony,
Sabertooth Zombie,
Life Long Tragedy,
Hummingbird of death ****
All the touring bands set up on the floor of the venue and pretty much tore shit up. This show was fun as hell.
Trash Talk,
The Carrier ****
Another fun-ass hardcore show. This one was in some kid's parents' garage out in Meridian. Funniest thing overheard that night: "I've never been hit that hard by a girl before."
Lair of the Minotaur ****
A rather average sort of "post-rock" band opened this show, and brought all their friends. After that, the place pretty much cleared out, which was a bummer. Hearing
Doomtrooper live made my night.
65daysofstatic ***
This is why I wish The Venue would book good bands with more care. Sorry, but I don't give a fuck about the scene it claims it represents, and I don't want to see a bunch of shitty high school talent show bands at every show I go to. All the opening bands were just shitty scene kids with nothing to offer, and absolutely nothing in common with 65daysofstatic, musically, aside from maybe using guitars and drums and maybe a few of the same notes here and there. I ended up getting my wristband and then wandering off and back for a few hours wishing I had money to get drunk, coming back every now and then to see if this local band sucked any less than the last one. 65daysofstatic ruled, and they were really solid dudes, but I felt kinda bummed for having paid like 10 bucks for one good band and four utterly terrible ones.
The Appleseed Cast,
The Impossible Shapes,
Browningham ****
Browningham was awesome, for a novelty act. Cheesy synthesizer pop and cheerleading routines. The Impossible Shapes surprised me with how good they were, too. I don't really like them on record, but live they took full advantage of that really harsh single-coil tone a lot of Fender guitars can get. The Appleseed Cast were in top form, and a hell of a lot of fun.
The Appleseed Cast,
Owen,
Acute ****
Acute weren't very good. Not awful, but nothing to get excited about. Mike Kinsella was a lot more fun live than I was expecting him to be, although I guess I shouldn't have been surprised given the other bands he's been in. The Appleseed Cast were just kinda settling in a new drummer, but sounded great regardless, even though the new drummer only knew a handful of songs. Copeland was headlining, but I left before they went on. Actually, a lot of people did. It seemed like most of the crowd was there to see The Appleseed Cast.
DragonForce,
HORSE the band,
All That Remains **
HORSE were a good opening band. Unfortunately, All That Remains were fucking terrible, and played an excruciating 40 minute set, most of which I spent outside in the smoker pit (note: I don't smoke; the venue the show was at just doesn't let people back in after they've left). Dragonforce were a lot of fun, even if they were pretty trashed while they played. But the venue was shitty and having to spend All That Remains' set within earshot just to hear Dragonforce left a really, really bad taste in my mouth about this one.
Jana Hunter **
Don't get me wrong. I like the songs. But her stage presence is boring, and the crowd talked over most of her set. Definitely a pretty underwhelming show that just kinda made me wish I'd stayed in, instead.
Weekend Nachos,
Hummingbird of death,
Riot on Rosewood,
Signs of Hope *****
This one was in a basement about the size of a small hallway. Shit was insane, awesome fun.
Charlie Louvin *****
This was a free show in a record shop. It was actually pretty great, and Charlie Louvin has held up surprisingly well considering his age. He still puts on a great show and I'd definitely recommend catching him live if you get the chance. I'd hurry, because there aren't anymore like him anywhere.
Isis,
Jesu,
Zozobra *****
Live is the only way to hear Isis. Their records are great, but their live set is something else entirely. They're a band that fully understands the psychedelic potential of repetition, and they're not afraid to use it. Jesu sounded great, and I wasn't that familiar with Zozobra as anything more than a "less wanky" Old Man Gloom sister band, but they were excellent, as well. This show was a hell of a lot of fun. So much fun that even being at a venue that's ruined or almost ruined a couple of the other shows on this list - easily the shittiest venue in town - couldn't ruin it.
Ted Leo and The Pharmacists,
Love of Diagrams *****
A fun show, for sure. Five stars by default because they played
The High Party and Dirty Old Town. Love of Diagrams were really good, too. Australian new-wavey stuff that somehow didn't come off as some kind of boring nostalgia thing. Both bands were really solid people after the show and were cool to hang out with the kids who stuck around. Always a plus, I think.
Fu Manchu,
Saviours ****
This show was really fun, but, unfortunately, I got really sick at it. Saviours put on a great set. Fu Manchu destroyed on a practically unprecedented level. Unfortunately, I went home with one of the worst colds I've ever had, and that's all that kept this from being a five star show.
Saviours,
Manville ****
I like Saviours live a lot better now that I know the songs better. And I liked them live to begin with. They seemed to be having a bit of an off-night, though. They didn't sound bad, but they didn't sound
great, either. Manville were pretty rad, too, of course. Those dudes are always good.
Kingdom of Magic,
Giants,
Fall From Grace **
Two stars because Kingdom of Magic and giants killed. These bands are both fucking great and I'd recommend seeing either of them. Minus one because they both played to about 12 people. Minus another two because most of the crowd left after Fall From Grace, by far the worst band I've heard in at least a year, played. Apparently they won a contest hosted by a company called... "Bodog." Seriously. Someone actually thought it would be cool to call a company "Bodog." Sounds like they either sponsor mixed martial arts or online gambling, or at least, something equally shitty that appeals exclusively to complete douchebags who vote for things with their cell phones. And apparently the prize for winning this contest was a record deal. I think their singer is trying to look like Mike Ness, but he just looks like that dork from Green Day, plus about fifty pounds. Fuck this band times a hundred.